Alien: Earth | "The Fly" Recap & Review | "Emergence" Preview

A Quiet Kirsh, a Warning from the Eye, and the Slow Burn Before the Storm

This week’s Alien Earth gave us what might be one of the slower installments of the season so far—but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t loaded with intrigue, unsettling moments, and the kind of lingering tension that the show has become known for.

Why Kirsh Stayed Silent About the Lab

One of the most talked-about elements of the episode was Kirsh’s unsettling silence after what he witnessed in the lab. Fans expected him to run to the others immediately, but instead, he kept it bottled up. Why? The most likely reason is fear—fear of not being believed, fear of drawing the eye creature’s attention to himself, and maybe even fear of what it means if what he saw is real. Kirsh has been portrayed as observant but cautious, and this moment reinforced that he’s someone who processes before he acts. Whether this decision saves him or damns him remains to be seen.

The Eye Monster and the Sheep’s Headbutt

The moment with the eye creature and the sheep is one of those scenes destined for endless fan theories. When the sheep suddenly headbutted the glass, it didn’t feel random. Was the creature controlling it as a demonstration of power—or was it a desperate attempt to warn the humans watching? The ambiguity is classic Alien Earth. The show loves to keep us second-guessing whether these alien beings are threats, allies, or something stranger. Personally, it felt more like a warning—an intentional jolt to show that whatever is in that lab isn’t as contained as the humans want to believe.

The Flying Insects vs. Toodles

Poor Toodles never stood a chance. The flying insect creatures—swift, swarming, and eerily coordinated—overwhelmed him in seconds. This wasn’t just about brute force, though. The insects seemed to move with purpose, as if directed by a hive mind. That kind of organization suggests they’re not just random predators, but something closer to soldiers. Toodles’ downfall was a reminder that on this world, size doesn’t guarantee survival.

Slightly’s Quest for Morrow

The other thread simmering in the background is Slightly’s obsession with finding Morrow. Each episode peels back a bit more of Slightly’s fixation, and this one hinted at desperation—he’s not just searching, he’s hunting. With Morrow’s whereabouts still a mystery, we’re clearly being set up for a collision that will reshape alliances. If Kirsh is the observer and Wendy the seeker, Slightly is the predator, and Morrow is the prey he can’t stop chasing.

The Slowest Episode So Far?

Let’s be real: this was not the most fast-paced hour of Alien Earth. After last week’s chaos, this episode hit the brakes and spent more time on atmosphere and character tension than action. Some fans may call it filler, but it feels more like setup—a necessary breather before the storm. The eerie silences, the lingering shots of the lab, the hesitation in Kirsh’s eyes… it all points toward a massive payoff coming soon.

Final Thoughts

This wasn’t the most explosive episode of the season, but it was a haunting one. It gave us more questions than answers, teased us with the Eye monster’s motives, and reminded us that on Alien Earth, even a sheep headbutt can leave you wondering if you just witnessed a warning of doom.

Next week? All signs point to Slightly’s hunt for Morrow coming to the forefront—and if the insects were this deadly, we can only imagine what’s waiting for him down the line.